Trimming Flying Wings
The goal in trimming a
flying wing is to get the center of gravity as far aft as possible and still
maintain stable control over pitch. Since the flying wing has very little tail
moment there is a tendency for the wing to be very pitch sensitive.
I think some sort of
exponential control is necessary to smoothly control most flying wings in the
pitch axis, while retaining the ability to have large control surface deflection
without using dual rates.
I typically set up my
wings with 100% neg. expo on both axis. Then I set the
deflection to at least 45 Deg. pos./neg. or 90 Deg. total deflection.
The roll axis is not as
sensitive. Differential aileron mixing is not recommended because it usually results
in pitch input while rolling.
The tail moment on a
flying wing is the distance from the elevon to the center of gravity. This is
usually not very far so the elevons don't have much leverage, but they are
usually very large compared to a horizontal stabilizer. This is why the CG
is so critical. If the wing is too nose heavy, it will require a lot of upward
deflection of the elevons to fly level.
This results in a lot of
unnecessary drag and sometimes a nose high attitude in level flight. It also
makes the wing far more stable in pitch response so it is best to start the
trimming procedure with some extra weight on the nose and a little reflex in
the elevons.
I have used the following
procedure for trimming R/C aircraft for some time and it is quite painless. You
start by finding a neutral trim for the wing. This is best done by setting up
everything as per the instructions (or your eyeball) and putting some
additional weight on the nose. I use tape and lead. Then add a click or two of
up
trim and either run with the plane or ride a bike (mobile wind tunnel) while
holding the plane level.
This will let you know if
it is close to its flying trim. At this point I like to use a bungee to
simulate a hard throw. I tape a hook a couple inches in front of the C.G. so
the plane will take off straight without trying to rotate as if it were on a
hi-start.
This will produce a
manageable launch that is high enough for trimming. On first launches I hold a
little bit of up elevon just to make sure it doesn't slam into the ground. I
usually have to put some down input to the wing after it comes off the hook
because I always set them up with too much up trim the first time. At this
point you will probably add some down trim and start launching harder. Once you
have the wing flying level in trim, you can move the nose weight back an inch
or two. This will cause it to have too much up trim so the process starts all
over again.
I generally keep moving
the weight back and re-trimming until I can barely control the pitch, then I
move it forward until I like it.
This determines the C.G. and the balance point you want for controllability. Once
you are sure about the C.G. you can dial in the wing for It's
best glide ratio and speed. This is very simple. When the wing is trimmed and
flying level you simply add a click of down trim and watch the wing. It should
nose down a bit and speed up. If it pulls out of the shallow dive by itself add
another click of down trim and watch it again.
You keep adding a click
of down until it stops pulling out of the dive by itself, and then add one
click of up trim and you are finished. Most gliders actually have a normal
oscillation cycle where they are going through the sky in repetitions of
shallow diving
and pulling out, but it is so shallow that it isn't noticeable if the plane is
in trim. Get to know the speed that the wing likes to fly at when in level
trim. It will probably be much faster than you thought it would be. It is
important to let it fly at this speed
if you are trying to maintain a good glide ratio. If you pull back on the stick
and try to "float" it, it will sink much faster than if it were at it’s
cruise speed.